The battle mental ray vs vray started many years ago and it seems that vray won in any aspect so far. I wouldnt call this a highend computer, maybe a mediumhigh computer at best. Mentalray vs vray in maya 2016 andrei serghiuta freelance. System here are the specifications for my machine that i did the testing on.
With the release of autodesk 3ds max 2018 software scheduled on april 12, 2017, autodesk will no longer include nvidias mental ray as part of 3ds max. As the leading render farm in the cg industry, fox renderfarm will answer this question in a personal opinions. Instead the company offers access to the arnold renderer developed by solid angle that was purchased by autodesk in. Anyway mental ray 2017 puts on the table some very good features at a. Another disadvantage of the mental ray setup was the more limited finalgather solution, which was much slower in generating a similar amount of bounced light in the scene as the vray gi. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to. I switched because when i hit my memory limit in mental ray which was 6gb at the time then it. Instead the company offers access to the arnold renderer developed by solid angle that was purchased by autodesk in 2016. Sep 12, 2019 hello everyone, i am a rhino user and i currently use 3ds max mental ray for my architectural renderings. Why vray is better than mental ray i too started with mental ray, and i didnt switch because of the render times, or even image quality really because i think its just as capable. With the release of 3ds max 2018 scheduled on april 12, 2017, autodesk will no longer include nvidias mental ray as part of 3ds max.
Its true, there are far more tutorials and forums on mental ray. Continuing to use mental ray or other nonbundled third party renderer v ray, renderman etc. Poliigon material converter addon for maya poliigon help center. This has come because of the exponential improvements undergone by older render engines. As of april 1, 2017, autodesk is ending the sale of mental ray standalone to new customers. To avoid this, cancel and sign in to youtube on your computer.
I am using autodesk maya 2016 and wondering which render engine should i choose, mental ray or v ray. Download unitys free digital asset packs for the heretic. The release of mental ray is discontinued as of 20 november 2017. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the faq by clicking the link above. Mental ray for 3ds max itself isnt available in nvidias online store yet. Speed compare for biased rendering no gi, no raytracing, if renderer support speed compare 1 unbiased rendering, physically based full global illumination with 3 light bounces. V ray gpu cuda now renders on cpus as well as gpus, to take full advantage of all available hardware. Videos you watch may be added to the tvs watch history and influence tv recommendations. I work with mental ray it comes standard with maya and i like it. While todays fast computers may ensure rendering crashes are less and less frequent, there are still instances when processing high resolution photorealistic renders will cause computers to freeze and ultimately crash. Here is some tips for setting up mental ray standalone for maya users successfully. Floating renderman licenses can be distributed across a network as needed, allowing the full utilization of all licenses on the renderfarm to. Hello everyone, i am a rhino user and i currently use 3ds max mental ray for my architectural renderings.
As we know, blender, maya and cinema 4d, all are 3d production software, and they can all make 3d animation. Blender vs maya vs cinema 4d, which one is the best 3d. Create highquality previz and animation tests via playblasts. Stop your render at any point and continue where you left off. Photorealistic renderman, or prman for short, is a proprietary photorealistic rendermancompliant renderer. Over the past few months i have been playing around with vray for maya, and also with adapting the material design method popularized by grant warwick to a maya workflow. We need to change our way to think a little bit between v2 and v3. This change does not affect existing licenses of mental ray standalone, which remain valid. Speed compare dx furryball rt incredibly fast gpu render.
Vray next for 3ds max is a complete lighting and shading solution that can be flawlessly integrated into every 3d artist and designers workflow. I do miss some aspects of mental ray as well, especially with materials. The battle mental ray vs v ray started many years ago and it seems that v ray won in any aspect so far. Vray benchmark is a free standalone application to help you test how fast your hardware renders. Why v ray is better than mental ray i too started with mental ray, and i didnt switch because of the render times, or even image quality really because i think its just as capable. From watching him work with it, v ray looks like its a bit more userfriendly and less technical than mental ray. Here are some of the advantages that i found to be extremely beneficial in everyday use. Most of the rendering tools can produce mindblowing renderings if. I used mental ray already and am interested to hear your thoughts, thank you by used i mean watched digital tutors tutorials about it and rendered a few images myself, but not an expert. I use vray all the time and find that the shaders are a bit lacking. Nvidia will no longer offer new subscriptions to the mental ray plugins for maya and 3ds max, as well as mental ray standalone from november 20, 2017 onward. Nvidia is to make mental ray for maya, the new plugin version of its production. For all users and lovers of mentalray and mental ray as we used to call it lately, in case you did not notice, i have sad news. From watching him work with it, vray looks like its a bit more userfriendly and less technical than mental ray.
Mitsuba for being really fast and having great results directly out of the box. May 30, 2017 we need to change our way to think a little bit between v2 and v3. Lightwave 3d modo rhinoceros 3d silo terragen vray vue zbrush sketchup. Theres also a blend material, which can be used to blend several other materials together to create more complex, layered materials. Continuing to use mental ray or other nonbundled third party renderer vray, renderman etc. Blender vs maya vs cinema 4d, which one is the best 3d software. Vray gpu cuda now renders on cpus as well as gpus, to take full advantage of all available hardware. Mental images was bought in december 2007 by nvidia.
Blender vs maya vs cinema 4d, which one is the best 3d software for animation. In this post, we test most of the major revit rendering tools. Determines whether a proxy is going to be rendered with materials connected to the original mesh, or materials connected to the proxy instance. The course instructor swears by vray because, according to him, its so much faster than mental ray. It also has a native hardware renderer and a vectorswf renderer to. Cpu render a mental ray gives you most control of the bunch but also the least intuitive. Paul dreisen graciously provided the original script but i tend to convert more between mayas materials and v ray than mental ray mats and i wanted to beef up the accuracy of conversion thats. Vray benchmark standalone app for testing cpu and gpu. May 20, 2007 you have a lot of renderers to choose from with maya. The vraymtlrenderstats can be used to specify additional render settings on a permaterial basis. Mental ray had a very slow development in the last 45 years and it didnt get any exciting new feature or update.
Also, for larger projects or environments, the vray proxy objects perform quite well. Vray next for sketchup now with support for sketchup 2019 sketchups most powerful rendering plugin by chaos group. In this test, we are mostly focused on the outofthebox capabilities. Speed compare 2 rasterisation furryball with cpu renderers furryball vs vray, furryball vs arnold, furryball vs mental ray, furryball vs renderman speed compare for biased rendering no gi, no raytracing, if renderer support speed compare 1 unbiased rendering, physically based full global illumination with 3 light bounces. The same settings can be accessed through the object properties, but if this material is used, it overrides those from the object properties. We have created an faq to help explain this change. As if nvidia didnt get enough exposure from my post, ill end this part with max prefers nvidia cards in all price segments so youre always better suited to choose an nvidia card over amd, even if you dont plan to use either iray or vray rt. As a brand new user to maya, this change comes at a great time.
New material swapper script that should replace the maya and mental ray mat to vray script for conversion of maya materials to vray mats and back. However i would like to switch to vray, but i dont know if the best solution for me is to stick to 3ds max and learn vray or to stay in rhino for the renderings and learn vray. The flagship rendering software has set the industry standard for speed, reliability, ease of use, and render quality. It primarily uses the reyes algorithm but is also fully capable of doing ray tracing and global illumination. Use maya shader for v ray proxies f or scenes created before v ray 3. I know that vray for 3ds max is really powerful and has tons of free online materials, which vray for. Nvidia is releasing mental ray for maya for free cg channel. For details see mental ray and iray product updates. Photorealistic renderman, or prman for short, is a proprietary photorealistic renderman compliant renderer. Also, for larger projects or environments, the v ray proxy objects perform quite well. Render high resolution images using vray or mental ray. If playback doesnt begin shortly, try restarting your device. If you need to buy mental ray, its a bit on the pricey side and is a yearly subscription, unless you have one of nvidias pro graphics cards, where its less. Read nvidia is releasing mental ray for maya for free.
The course instructor swears by v ray because, according to him, its so much faster than mental ray. I wanted to do a comparison, so this is a showdown of the 3 render engines i could get access to, and that i could make work on my system. As the name implies, it supports ray tracing to generate images. Theyre improving the interface a lot as of late and since its free anyway you should give it a shot and see if you like it. Anyway mental ray 2017 puts on the table some very good features at a cheaper price than v ray. Ive been working with an old version of vray for a few years now, but lecturing in mental ray, so im very familiar with both. Sep 12, 2014 3ds max 2018 maxtoa plugin arnold interior lighting part 34 duration. So far, my experience with vray has been mostly very good, and i find it significantly better than the mental ray experience in maya. Best software for modeling and rendering forum archinect. Current customers who have purchased licenses from nvidia will continue to receive support, software updates through our advanced rendering forum for the remainder of their subscription. This article contains answers to frequently asked questions.
To enable sequence rendering, batch rendering and rendering on a network, youll need full production licences of mental ray. Bundling a single interactiveonly license wont make anybody but the smallest facility or freelance operation consider changing renderers imo. Render high resolution images using vray or mental ray by jamie cardoso. Usually 2k movies use an rendering time of about one hour per frame, while hollywood mainstream movies have resolutions of 2k, 4k, 6k, and 8k, and each quality time will increase by four times. New material swapper script that should replace the maya and mental ray mat to vray script for conversion of maya materials to v ray mats and back. Mental ray vs vray nowadays it is extremely difficult for artists to decide what render engine they are going to use.
Added to this is the stiff competition between gpubased and cpubased render engines. Vray rt is to vray what iray is to mental ray a vray port to work on dedicated nvidia cuda technology. Yet mitsuba, octane and vray all came very close in the end, and are all quite equally noisefree. Interior scenes are quite problematic to render since an important part of the lighting. Mayas native renderer is fast but lacks things like gi, hdri, caustics. A single renderman license can be used either for batch rendering or for rendering with an artist seat.
Renderman and maxwell are 2 you might also want to look at. Mental ray stylized as mental ray is a productionquality rendering application developed by mental images berlin, germany. Speed compare 2 rasterisation furryball with cpu renderers furryball vs vray, furryball vs arnold, furryball vs mental ray, furryball vs renderman. The same properties are also present in every shape of a maya node. V ray next for sketchup now with support for sketchup 2019 sketchups most powerful rendering plugin by chaos group. In the end, i just decided to reduce the finalgather settings a bit and reduce the render time significantly. Vray vs mental ray comparison, test and speed benchmark.
Yet mitsuba, octane and v ray all came very close in the end, and are all quite equally noisefree. Personally im not a fan of vray and max as its very hard to get the same qualityintent as maya and mental rayrenderman and a. Prman is produced by pixar animation studios and used to render all of their inhouse 3d animated movie productions. Home forums 3dsmax scriptswanted vray to mental ray.
Render engine comparison cycles vs iray vs renderman. You have a lot of renderers to choose from with maya. If you want to test drive this 3d rendering software, download the free. In maya 2017, autodesk has replaced nvidias mental ray with arnold for maya. The most important one is the standard vray material, this will be the base for most of the materials you will create.
359 1167 582 688 1276 1147 1235 26 136 893 1536 1455 1280 1467 373 1151 1115 611 408 1339 622 1212 528 1098 65 441 334 1094 1025 843 1185 1396 920 1131 1225 66 94 1088 770 5 1340 1250 180